Monday, March 18, 2013

Tony Brandenburg: Gimme Gimme

Right now would be good
Hyperbolic Overdrive
Last week there was a PUSD Board meeting. Mary was there, but I was not. It was the first meeting I have missed in a while.

I was in Austin at something called South by Southwest (SXSW) playing music alongside bands like Clutch, Orange Goblin, and Fidlar for Thrasher Magazine and Converse Sneakers. Playing music doesn’t pay my bills, but it is a second income, and it is helpful.

One thing I missed was the teacher who spoke and shared that she was having trouble making ends meet. It was along the lines of being near poverty level and not being able to afford hot water. At $74,000 a year ... I dunno, that sounds iffy. Head Librarians and counselors in the PUSD make more than teachers in PUSD, btw. Whatever (click here). Everyone needs work and should be paid whatever they want to be paid, right?

I happen to know, and I like this particular hot waterless teacher - and understand her frustration, but times are tough and we all have to give up something. Though, I don’t think hot water has to be it.

Listen. I make about the same amount of money as that teacher. I have two teaching credentials, and a Master’s Degree. I have been in the classroom for 25 years. That is the standard salary. There may be a slight variation between counties, but it is slight. I believe I am receiving a competitive salary for public education.

Deal with it, or play cards at a different table.

Yes, I am saying that Ed Honowitz (click here) is not to blame for the Pasadena teachers lacking hot water. He is the cause of a great deal of idiocracy (click here), and that is going lightly, believe me - but not the lack of hot water. I’m not saying he should be cleared of anything (click here). Ever.

I chose to work in education, not in management. I could have gone into management, but I didn’t. You couldn’t pay me enough to be an Edwin Phone-Bone Diaz (click here), MichaelThe Phantom Jason, or Elizabeth Bucking Blanco. I still have a soul, however charred you may believe it to be.

You couldn’t pay me enough to teach in special education pseudo-management either. I applied for a program specialist job once. I was interviewed by a communication teacher who had narcolepsy. She used to fall asleep in my classroom every week. She was, of course, immediately promoted, and a year later I was interviewed by her. I was better qualified for the job she held because I had a teaching credential which Communication Specialists do not.

During the interview I told her I was better qualified for her job, and that being interviewed for a position by her was the equivalent to being interviewed by the Head of Special Education who had an administrative credential, but no background in special education. He was also present for the interview. They smiled - but the smile was not in their eyes. Insincere smiles. Easy to spot.

I was chuckling, and as happy as could be. A regular old grinning loon.

The next series of questions were simulations to determine how I would respond to situations in which parents and district were in conflict. I answered every question - there were four - as honestly as I could. I told them I would do what I came into this field to do - I would advocate for the children. I explained in all four scenarios how the district had violated the children’s rights to a free and appropriate education.

One of my interviewers was sleeping before I finished my interview.

When I got home I told Mary that I interviewed well, and that I was proud that I would not get the position. The person who did get the job was a communication specialist. All of the positions of this nature went to them. The structure of most districts is to support these in-demand professionals because they are the hardest to keep without incentives.

Within six months all three people had left the district to go somewhere else. One of them even got an award from Elizabeth Blanco along the way. Awards are generally a way ineffective people recognize one another for their mediocrity.

I accepted my role, teacher, and never applied for another position like that again.

I am a teacher. I am proud, overworked, underpaid, and smart enough to know what is important in this field. The kids.

Listen. I accept my curse (click here). I make $75,000. I have more education than I know what to do with, and I have always been more interested in processes that in products. That doesn’t sit well in a data driven field based on loose numbers and fluctuating statistics.

In my life I support myself, and four other people on that check. Oh, and a little dog. When I can, I play rock and roll shows to raise money for myself, also for friends who are ill, and also for people who are down on their luck. I have no regrets. I believe in people and I help as much as I can. I also have hot water.

However, if Pasadena teachers lack water that is hot, I suggest the United Teachers of Pasadena take it up with their city, and not with the PUSD School Board. The World Class City Council sets up those limits in water and power. The mayor’s name is Mr. Bogaard. Just in case you didn’t know.

Tell him I said, “Hi!”

Salaries and Hyperbole
Back in the 2010/2011 school year my child was being taught by a teacher who also serves on the local union’s executive board. Dig the rhetoric. The teacher used all of the correct lingo, family, community, partnership, focused, cooperative, open door policy, pro-volunteerism. It all sounded so good. Who wouldn’t succeed in a place like that? It sounded like Romper Room. Everyone had a place in such an environment, right?

Well, yes and no.

Everyone but the Brandenburgs. See, this teacher was in charge when everything in my child’s life went to hell, and when I had a heart attack. In fact, she was the teacher in charge when my child was being removed for hours at a time from instruction, and then placed into a storage classroom. I am not saying she had knowledge of this, but she was the teacher in charge so it doesn’t really matter, does it?

Teacher/Rep’s salary that year according to salary records was close to $98,000. Not bad. $25,000 more than I earn, and half of my experience.

In fact, take a look at what the salaries of the starving Sierra Madre staff are, and everyone else. Keep this in mind - more than ten of these people are the very same people who called me at work - making it impossible for me to do my job, causing me significant stress, disrupting my family, and then eventually declaring all out war on us.

These were fellow teachers - and instead of supporting our family, they set the dogs of hell loose on us. They called me, again and again, essentially telling me that they weren’t capable of doing their jobs. So, I suppose it was the right time to punish me for it.

The difference between Local Teacher/Rep and I?  I can handle students like my son, for a comparable cost - or less - and teachers like her can’t. Or won’t.

Local Teacher/Rep, at a salary of $98,000 a year - cried in the staff room, situated right next to the cafeteria where all of the parent volunteers would be at lunch, and to Gayle Bluemel - her administrator, and to Elizabeth Blanco - the head of special education, and directly to a couple of parents, too.

$98,000.

Not too shabby for a teacher who couldn’t handle a seven year old autistic kid.

Not too shabby at all.

Politics Make Strange Bedfellows
See, in politics, things are kind of tricky. There was some protesting going on back then, it usually happens every few years, and some years management and teachers are best pals (click here), and some years they are bitter rivals. This year is a bitter rivalry year.

That means people are going to be mean to each other.

Back when my son was the talk of the town, though, that was a year of palsy-walsy between the teachers and the management.

Well, maybe there’s more to the tale that none of you knew (click here).

Listen. Local Teacher wasn’t just your average second grade teacher. She was, and I assume is - on the Executive Board (click here) for the United Teachers of Pasadena.  When I met with Elizabeth Blanco in November, 2010, this information was made very clear to me by Blanco.

Blanco told me the teacher was a union representative. What Blanco didn’t make clear, but what I knew, was that the situation as it stood would be a case of PUSD and the union rep working cooperatively and sacrificing a child - my child - for what they called the greater good in that particular year - of friendship between management, and workers. They even brought in some parent volunteers to document it all. That my friends, is called politics.

I am sitting on 700 pages of documents about what happened to my child at Sierra Madre Elementary School. I am well aware of what went down.

I discovered a couple of photos of Blanco and Local 2nd Grade Teacher/Rep marching together out in front of PUSD to raise awareness of educational cutbacks a couple years back (click here). That was one of those cooperative years.

Keep this stuff in mind when United Teacher President Alvin “$102,000 a year” Nash is complaining about the salaries of administrators and the pink slips that have been handed out every year since the district began (click here).

Keep that $102,000 salary in mind when the UTP refuses to provide fair meeting times for working parents of families of special ed students who can’t afford to attend IEP meetings during work hours if it conflicts with teacher hours (download February Voice click here) even though this is a Federally mandated law that is being rejected outright by the far more legally pressing local union.

Keep that $102,000 salary in mind when UTP reject the furloughs every other district in the area takes. For example, the neighboring local district, Arcadia Unified has something like seven furlough days (click here). Glendale takes six (click here), and Baldwin Park takes seven (click here). Yet the United Teachers of Pasadena which represents teachers in Pasadena won’t take 5 days (click here) to save teacher jobs?

Maybe your NEA bargaining unit should be replaced with a different bargaining agent. They aren’t the only one. Ooops, did I say that?

I personally have had to take furlough days for a few years now, and we saved lots of jobs. Sadly, not all. I spend $500+ monthly for benefits. Hot water still working, btw.

Although there seems to be a dysfunction in UTP salaries that I noticed, don’t bring it up because it runs contrary to the UTP Code of Conduct. LOL.

For added fun, check out the endorsement of Ruben Hueso, which the UTP rescinded after they actually took the time to research him (click here). The same UTP that didn’t respond to my two emails about this situation - a story I sat on out of respect to Hueso and the UTP. I promise you this: next time I hear a rumor attached to the UTP I won’t bother to check out its authenticity. UTP doesn’t care to respond.

Just remember, UTP, we are not stupid, uneducated proles. You cannot feed us propaganda and expect us to just believe you. Treat us with the same respect and dignity you serve to one another. Don’t feed us hyperbole, and don’t feed us rhetoric. We will hand it right back.

Some People Never Learn
You will recall the recent dispute between a Tattler and Sierra Madre School in which children were being solicited for political actions (click here). The situation was pretty obnoxious:

Apparently the "Extra Credit" e-mail from a "class mom" went out to quite a few Sierra Madre Elementary School parents, and offered them some time off from homework and extra points for attending a partisan political rally in favor of these two ballot initiatives. 

It was pointed out that this was a big no-no. Apparently the UTP Executive Board Member didn’t get the memo from October 23, 3012 and notify her colleagues and parents:

Ed code prohibits the district from being involved formally and giving the kids extra credit is formal involvement.  Please let Ms. Salinas know immediately they can't do this tomorrow w/ the kids.

On Friday they were out passing out a bright pink flyer titled, PUSD Budget: Millions of Dollar$ and No Sense to parents and to children out in front of Marshall Fundamental. I know, because I watched them do it. I also got a flyer, as did an autistic person I know. I wonder what that autistic individual would have thought had I explained that one of the sources of said flyer helped to remove an autistic child from a public school. I am looking at one that my son was given right now, thank you very much.

Even a twelve year old knows propaganda when it’s handed to him.

http://sierramadretattler.blogspot.com

82 comments:

  1. "Awards are generally a way ineffective people recognize one another for their mediocrity"-
    Absolutely, PUSD has a special way of saying goodbye to those who slip up.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Honowitz is getting one of those special PUSD awards.

      Delete
    2. For what? Politically Correct Fogbanking?

      Delete
  2. Brandenburgs: Not only does the Board of Education owe your family minimally an apology- the UTP owes your child, and your family an apology.

    A UTP EXECUTIVE BOARD member? This teacher sat back and let your son be caged in solitary confinement? Something's wrong here.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. TB, have you brought this up to the UTP? Is there something in the union bylaws about caging students?

      Delete
    2. If one of the UTP leadership was the case carrier, or teacher involved, do you think it is something they want to discuss?

      Delete
    3. Of course not 9:24, but if the teacher was involved, shouldn't there be accountabilty through the UTP?

      Delete
  3. The teacher who was whining about making $74,000 a year needs some education on how people really struggle, and on how many people live on a lot less than that.
    She hurts teachers and makes them targets for resentment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 7:10, you're absolutely correct. There are teachers who are single vs. those that raise a family on that salary. It's not fair, but the resentment will be sent to both.

      Delete
  4. $98,000 for a teacher is getting very close to upper administrator salaries. What's the complaint about?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maybe there are teachers accepting administrator salaries who are not actually administrating?

      Delete
    2. Ah, the permutations of "accepting", "not actually" as in teacher salaries, not actually teaching...

      Delete
    3. Sad part is that there are teachers in PUSD who are excellent, and were handed pink slips.
      They are the ones not getting $98,000 a year- for teaching the same amount of hours. Their colleagues refuse to take even a single furlough day that teachers in ALL SURROUNDING DISTRICTS take. That little sacrifice would save the jobs of how many teachers?

      Delete
    4. This is something else that needs to be considered. Regardless of the budget, and anything else, a teacher needs to have specific qualifications to be considered at years end for a contract the following year. No matter how good, they need to meet state credential qualifications or the district have to fly the position as a vacancy.

      Delete
    5. Yes 3:20, you're right. This year though, I think the difference is that they've gotten the ok to cut a certain number of positions.

      Delete
  5. How is it that local districts have all been doing furlough days and PUSD has not? Or is it that UTP won't accept ADDITIONAL days?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They won't accept them. Do they think they are better than Arcadia? Baldwin Park?

      Delete
    2. My understanding is that teachers are following the advice of their $102,000 UTP president who doesn't sacrifice a penny of his salary to help his colleagues who are actually IN the classrooms, serving the students.

      Delete
  6. These teachers who make such big bucks also have lots of benefits that many people in the private sector no longer have. They will soon be as disliked as city government workers are if they keep up the victim game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Why is there such disparity among teacher salaries? How can some teachers make $100,000 and others make only $50,000? Who's the union representing?

      Delete
    2. The pay scale is a grid. Number of years worked and post grad degrees or units.
      You get a raise every year. If you take classes or get an advanced degree you get another boost.

      Delete
    3. And of course the grade level being taught: preschool, kindergarten, elementary, middle school, high school.

      Delete
  7. Mr. Brandenburg, are you a member of a teacher's union? Do you benefit from their support?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mr. 7:49 are you now, or have you ever been, a member of the Communist Party?

      Delete
    2. If you teach in a public school you are forced to join the union.

      Delete
    3. And to pay union dues 9:13. Since the district foots the UTP president's $100k salary, what do the dues pay for?

      How come the UTP president doesn't take a few furlough days himself? Or a salary reduction to support his colleagues that are instead losing their jobs?

      Delete
    4. please don't misinterpret this as meaning I am anti-union. I am actually very pro union, but I also believe that union should work with districts to problem solve when money is tight. I don't believe that is happening right now.

      I also believe in utilizing the public support ONLY when talks shut down (I don't see that shutdown happening here)and only when the facts are used, not hyperbole and not propaganda. That builds distrust.

      My goal is, and always has been, to exact apologies to my child from those directly involved, and if they were in a position of knowing that it is due, then it should be provided. I don't care if they are union, board, administrator, or pta.

      I will continue to research and share what I find until that day comes.

      Delete
  8. I have a question, TB: How is it possible for a Union contract to supercede federal law? Who negotiated a contract that denied parents of special needs students options for meetings?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It happens because the district is afraid of the teachers, afraid of the parents, and afraid of the press. it is as simple as a statent indicating to the union that the language of the contract opens the district open for litigation,.

      Delete
    2. 3:55, this information was presented to the Board, and to Human resources- by the Spec Ed Task force. They've been notified that the UTP contract is in violation of Federal law that states meetings are to be arranged at a "mutually agreed upon time". Dr. Jason is still rummaging through the task force recommendations- given to the Board LAST May.

      Ask any special ed parent what happens. They are given a day/time during school hours.
      They are asked if it's ok to hold the meeting without them if they can't be there at that time. Look at the UTP voice for February that Tony mentions in the article. The union reminds teachers that they have the contract to support them insisting on meeting during their contracted hours- which is 20 minutes after the students leave.

      Delete
    3. thank you 5:05. i am not always clear. this is a glitch in the contract that i have been trying to get across to both sides of this discussion for a few years. long story short, but it happened because i went to an IEP meeting twice for the same reason, only to have them cancel- and i had given up sick days to attend. For the next two years i was blamed for not trying to accommodate the teachers schedules by giving up more of my own personal sick days and vacation days. tb

      Delete
  9. Moderator, what's happened to the Tattler hiatus? Was that all a ruse?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tony Brandenburg wrote today's post.

      Delete
    2. Is John still moderating? Will he be having guest Tattlers?

      Delete
    3. I've been watching since Friday. The omments are appearing and seem to be moderated; Mr. TB's very excellent and provocative post is up today; and carefully selecte vintage pots appeared over the weekend. What's different? The Tattler continues...

      Delete
    4. Don't fret 11:03 am. It's only Steve the Unicorn wrangler that's trying to ferret out information. I hear they're monitoring the airports to see when Crawford heads to Portland. They're knerpted and kerfuffled to be sure.

      Delete
    5. Probably causing them to suffer from sparkle dysfunction.

      Delete
    6. I hear the Tattler hired a blog consultant.

      Delete
    7. The Tattler "hired" a blog consultant? I don't think you fully comprehend the fiscal policies of the Moderator...

      Delete
    8. You may need to hire a lawyer to start fielding these questions. See if You can bill PUSD. They like to pay for lawyers and consultants.

      Delete
    9. I miss Crawford.

      Delete
    10. I don't think he's gone, is he?

      Delete
    11. "Hiatus" dear Steve.

      Delete
    12. I saw him at Happy's buying lottery tickets.

      Delete
    13. There was a moderator sighting at the vine. I think he was buying a wistaria fete sipper hat. later sightings of the mod placed him dressed in green, and dancing on the ceiling of the buc with our very own mayor josh who was also wearing said supper hat.

      Delete
    14. Lady Hysteria, methinks you have meadow muffin dust in your eyes.

      Delete
  10. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5k0Ex55stmE

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for the post TB. I especially like the photos of the smiling little kidos marching with the poor teachers. I wish I could supply a photo of my 8 year old from this past week. Screaming and crying not to go back to the teacher who has been harassing her since the Oct, 2012 complaint was filed regarding her politics in the classroom. I have gotten the PUSD shuffle ever since. She has missed a week of school, been isolated, harassed and bullied by an adult that makes damn near 6 figures? I thought teachers were to care about children, I thought that is why they became teachers. They have placed my child in a new class as of today. This morning, while I show up for 7:35 meeting with the "site principal" to meet the new teacher, the "site principal" is a NO SHOW. Nice... maybe she had a bit to much Irish whisky yesterday? 98k will buy ya some nice top shelf stuff I imagine. PUSD likes us people to go away. I for one will not, as no child should be treated the way my daughter has been. Yeah the "poor teachers" Pffffffft

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey bbqg, is that you in the graphic today? It's how I picture you as a child! Absolutely darling and a force to contend with.

      Delete
    2. no not me, at that age, I was cutting my own dews, usually missing big chunks here and there...

      Delete
  12. This should be a direct link to the PUSD staff salaries. This is a public record.

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AlVE0Dg50PejdHVHTXBhSHh4TUloeGQ0SzNMVUx5SEE#gid=0

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for posting the salary information. Very enlightening. I wonder if the teachers have seen it.

      Delete
    2. Check out the data on "teachers on special assignment". That's code word for teacher working as an administrator and doing less because no one knows what your function is. They make $90,000 +

      Delete
    3. The best use of these moneys were "Inclusion Specialists" who were paid these great wages based on what? Well, on nothing because there was no definition of the term "Inclusion" in PUSD. Since the Brandenburg child was technically in an "Inclusion Classroom," what exactly was the class function if it was not a defined entity in the first place?

      Delete
    4. Who cares! Show me the Mo' Money!

      Delete
    5. I wonder if the PUSD teachers know how much their UTP pres gets while bad mouthing the administrators who make the same, or even less than him.

      Delete
  13. Are those salaries for the typical school year (9 months) or do they include work (such as summer school) over the summer months?
    I wouldn't mind making $100k a year and taking summers off!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hello TF. Those look like fixed salaries, so those don't include extra duty pay. it is possible that some are special assignments, but not most.

      Delete
    2. @True Freedom: Those salaries are for the typical school year. The supplemental pay is not included. That's also not including benefits.

      Delete
    3. I honestly don't understand how it can be justified to pay an out of the classroom teacher/UTP Pres $102k. Teachers should be hitting him up, just as they hit up the administrators.

      Delete
    4. It is against the code to ask.

      Delete
    5. Gayle Bluemel made $66,000 for part of a year!

      Delete
    6. Ah yes, Bluemel was paid well to sing and dance her way through an Office of Civil Rights investigation, lying through her teeth. "What petition? I don't know anything about a petition." We have the email showing that it was sent to her, by her PTA pal.

      ~Mary

      Delete
    7. The Boscas made her Grand Marshall of our 4th of July parade and she didn't even live here. Too bad PETA didn't stop her as well.

      Delete
    8. Wait'll you get a look at what replaces it.

      Delete
  14. I taught public high school for 31.5 years and retired with no where near $100k. Most teachers do not and those who do did a lot of scrambling to augment their salary with summer school, extra paid assignments. I am sure you will not find that salary on any regular schedule. As far as summers off, consider it compensation for all the week-ends of grading papers, meeting with parents, faculty meetings and unpaid committees, preparing lesson plans, and more all the stuff that does not take place during the "work" day.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Oh it's a glorious day in the SM, just rolled into town past rhe now half demolished SNF, yes indeed a glorious day!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh why demolish it? I really liked the "South LA look" it gave our main Blvd.

      Delete
  16. LA Times today had an piece on how an area in the San Fernando Valley is fighting zoning changes to allow "Costco-sized" AlFs,etc in their single family residences.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I can't bear to watch the destruction of that low impact Sierra Madre institution--there was a birth center there, a battered woman's center, the pharmacy, the doctor's offices, the nursing home where my father was for a number of years and the hospital where a dear friend convalesced for a few days after a fall. Sadness all the way around to see the hedious monster building and the greed that it represents built there instead.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Temple of Doom.

      Delete
    2. It is kind of like Roach Motel. They check in, but they don't check out.

      Delete
    3. Nu-uh 6:58. They don't deal with dying patients at a facility like the Kensington. They ship them out before that.

      Delete
  18. Why wasn't the ALF proposal ever required to plant story poles in the gound so that we could really see how monsterous it is going to be? Sierra Madre will be shocked to learn the final size and how it looms over our town forever more.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Here's the part I don't get:
    The Assisted Living Facility, the British Home expansion, the mansions to house bathrooms in the hillsides, Dr. Sami's new digs, the restaurant/s - office/s across the street from him, the condos on Sierra Place - and we have a water shortage? Really?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Not after that new MWD pipe is hooked up and on-line!

      Delete
    2. It's only for emergencies. You know, like when we build an ALF, a DSP or One Crater McMansions.

      Delete
  20. I bet they waited until John was on hiatus to start tearing down the ALF so no one in town would notice.

    ReplyDelete
  21. What an asinine comment 8:59 made, and what a total putz that would post something like that, unbelievable!

    ReplyDelete